If you have not started working on a new codebase while adopting AI, it may be harder to realize the gains.
I switched jobs somewhat recently. At my previous job, where I was on the codebase for years, I knew where the changes should be and what they should look like. So I tried to jump directly to implementation with the AI because I didn't need much help planning and the AI got confused and did an awful job.
In a new codebase, where I had no idea how things are structured, I started the process by using AI to understand where the relevant code is, the call hierarchies and side effects, etc.
I have found by using the AI to conduct the initial investigation, it was then very easy to get the AI to generate an effective spec, and then it was relatively easy to get the AI to generate the code to that spec. That flow works much better than trying to one shot implementation
It sounded like he was trying to one shot things when he mentioned he would ask it to fix problems with no luck. It's an approach I've tried before with similar results, so I was sharing an alternative that worked for me. Apologies if it came across as dismissive
GP said they were doing vibe coding and trying to get the ai to do one shots. Thats the worst way to use these tools. AI coding agents work best when you generally know what you want the output to look like but dont want to waste time writing that output
I switched jobs somewhat recently. At my previous job, where I was on the codebase for years, I knew where the changes should be and what they should look like. So I tried to jump directly to implementation with the AI because I didn't need much help planning and the AI got confused and did an awful job.
In a new codebase, where I had no idea how things are structured, I started the process by using AI to understand where the relevant code is, the call hierarchies and side effects, etc.
I have found by using the AI to conduct the initial investigation, it was then very easy to get the AI to generate an effective spec, and then it was relatively easy to get the AI to generate the code to that spec. That flow works much better than trying to one shot implementation