I've tried both. One time I actually tried so hard that I ran out of context, and aider just dumped me back to the main prompt. I don't think It's possible to guide it any more than that.
My problem is that the solution is right there in the paper. I just have to understand it. Without first understanding that paper, I can't possibly guide the AI towards a reasonable implementation. The process of finding the implementation is exactly the understanding of the paper, and the AI just doesn't help me with that. In fact, all too often I would ask it to make some minor change, and it would start making random changes all over the file, completely destroying my mental model of how the program worked. Making it change that back completely pulls me out of the problem.
When it's a junior at my job, at least I can feel like I'm developing a person. They retain the conversation and culture I impart as part of the problem solving process. When I struggle against the computer, it's just a waste of my time. It's not learning anything.
I'm still really curious what you're doing with it.
My problem is that the solution is right there in the paper. I just have to understand it. Without first understanding that paper, I can't possibly guide the AI towards a reasonable implementation. The process of finding the implementation is exactly the understanding of the paper, and the AI just doesn't help me with that. In fact, all too often I would ask it to make some minor change, and it would start making random changes all over the file, completely destroying my mental model of how the program worked. Making it change that back completely pulls me out of the problem.
When it's a junior at my job, at least I can feel like I'm developing a person. They retain the conversation and culture I impart as part of the problem solving process. When I struggle against the computer, it's just a waste of my time. It's not learning anything.
I'm still really curious what you're doing with it.