> Fundamentally this should have been sorted with a properly designed trial with the correct protocol of sufficient size to answer the question. Given what was on the line why has it not been done?
That's an interesting question but if you're suggesting it implies something either direction: why?
Obviously there are a LOT of politicians and people strongly interested in a "masks are useless" position.
But it's not just that the "masks are useful" people have failed to satisfy you.
It's also that the "masks are not useful" crowd has not published a conclusive study of their own.
So it's not convincing to me that the truth is anything other than "masks have varying effectiveness, though the supply-chain-crunch plain-cloth-mask world of 2020 wasn't the ideal type of mask."
Do you have reason to believe an N95 isn't effective? What about a P99? (In the world of media I consume, these types of masks vs cloth masks are things that were widely discussed, along with PM2.5 etc. So the "it was presented as black and white" crowd seems just uniformed of their own volition, maybe watching too much partisan media who had an interest in presenting the issue in a one-sided manner.)
That's an interesting question but if you're suggesting it implies something either direction: why?
Obviously there are a LOT of politicians and people strongly interested in a "masks are useless" position.
But it's not just that the "masks are useful" people have failed to satisfy you.
It's also that the "masks are not useful" crowd has not published a conclusive study of their own.
So it's not convincing to me that the truth is anything other than "masks have varying effectiveness, though the supply-chain-crunch plain-cloth-mask world of 2020 wasn't the ideal type of mask."
Do you have reason to believe an N95 isn't effective? What about a P99? (In the world of media I consume, these types of masks vs cloth masks are things that were widely discussed, along with PM2.5 etc. So the "it was presented as black and white" crowd seems just uniformed of their own volition, maybe watching too much partisan media who had an interest in presenting the issue in a one-sided manner.)