Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Shameless relevant plug: that's the exact goal of Vale! [0]

It turns out, when one removes the borrow checker, they get something that's much more readable, because a lot of Rust's complexity was added to help support the borrow checker.

Ironically, we can then add back in a different, easier form of borrow checking to get the speed benefits.

[0] https://vale.dev/



> Rust is also very difficult. It's as complex as C++, and throws it all at the programmer at once.

I thin Rust isnt nearly as complex


It definitely is. You've probably just had more time to discover the complexity of C++ (and read about it, since it's actually specified).

Of course Rust's complexity is much less dangerous because if you forget some obscure rules you get a compile error instead of UB (in safe Rust at least).


Vale sounds very promising (I'm also closely following Koka). But one thing I've found is that Rust's ownership/borrowing model does more than just eliminate GC. It also seems to encourage good program structure that is less prone to logic bugs.

I don't have solid evidence for that - more of a feeling. But I wonder if switching to reference counting would lose that.

Anyway, just an observation.


It's refreshing to see such a simple, good-looking and informative website. Also incredibly fast! Please keep it that way.


Vale looks exciting. Thanks for the link.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: