Doesn't cloudfare do this? (extremely extensively imo - just about every single click is a captcha of some type sometimes)
As much as HN despises blockchains because of crypto, (no, that's not the only use of that tech) it does seem like verification of websites could be a decentralized consensus - along with DNS as well -and user verification could be a portion of the consensus of website quality.
This could even help with making self hosted search engines more accessable
Hmm, or you outsource the trust problem to your users. Let them select which domains to trust or who to trust to weight trustworthiness of domains for you.
Imagine that user A can create a list of domains with trustworthiness score. User B can then use that list by going to user-a-awesome-curation.koogle.com?q=nice+shoes
It might create filter bubbles but it would be transparent filter bubbles. You could even wikify/open source the curation.