Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Can I install this locally? Will it work without an internet connection? Is it fully open source? From what I can tell, the answer to all three questions is no.

Is it yet another example of vendor lock-in? Yes.



The underlying technology (https://vitess.io/) is fully open source, so I imagine there will be very little vendor lock in.


There is still value in proprietary solutions that offer significant time/money savings vs open source. Not all of us have infinite resources to develop and maintain every solution in-house, whether that's an auto-scaling database or email or Google Docs or whatever.

For small/medium businesses, sometimes it's better just to let the experts do their thing and build on top of it...


If it is MySQL compatible it's not vendor lock in.

It's more like a clever trap, first hit is free etc.

Will be interesting to follow this. I'm not db savvy so I don't mind leaving that job to someone else.


Vender lock-in isn't just about data formats, it's about the overall makeup of your infrastructure and development processes. If an org builds around the particular way PlanetScale manages DB branches and other minutiae of their service, they can't simply replace that with an in-house DB server overnight.


True enough, but by that standard, every service would constitute lock-in. A cleaning company isn't lock-in just because you don't have in-house janitors.

"Vendor lock-in" means that you're tied at a business-critical level to some proprietary technology _that you can't get anywhere else_.

If you rent Linux servers, Postgres databases, or even k8s setups from Azure, there's no shortage of alternative vendors willing to sell you compatible product should you tire of MS, and ideally you won't need to change much more than a few endpoints. However, if your entire user base lives in Azure AD, it's a very different story.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: