Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Doug Hurley was the pilot on the shuttle crew that left the flag on the ISS, and will be the commander of the crew that brings it back to Earth.


There are several very large assumptions implicit in that sentence.


Hurley is going to be the "Spacecraft Commander" as mentioned in the article. The parent comment also indicates that they will be bringing the flag/memorial/token back. I'm not sure what "large implicit assumptions" you are referring too.


He means that flight or its currently designated commander may not make it to the ISS for various reasons.

I don't think those are "large" assumptions, they're pretty standard things that can go wrong with every flight. Not that useful to have to enumerate them every time anyone talks about spaceflight.


- mission not being scrubbed for a variety of possible reasons

- mission commander not being changed

- rocket not blowing up on the pad

- rocket reaching correct orbit

- mission not being completed, for instance docking issues

- everything that could possibly go wrong on the return flight

Really, the ease with which everybody seems to assume that this will go off without a hitch is impressive, this is not exactly walking to the corner store to pick up a small parcel.


You must be real fun at parties.....

Friend: I'm going to grab more drinks from the store

You: There are several very large assumptions implicit in that sentence

Friend: ?

You: Your car can break down, you can get in an accident on the way there, the store can be robbed and you can get shot, you may get a call about your parents dying on the way, a meteor may strike and kills us all...


I would love to party at jacquesm, we could talk about all the ways that civilization is a rube goldberg machine.


Why do you assume people assumed that? I mean, these are things that apply to every human spaceflight on any rocket in any country.

Imagine if anytime anyone spoke about spaceflight, they saw fit to include a giant disclaimer of everything that could go wrong. We'd all just end up sounding like drug commercials.


> walking to the corner store to pick up a small parcel

* You could sprain your ankle and not make it

* The parcel might have been stolen by a robber

* The corner store might be on fire

* Feral dogs might chase you to the other side of town


You forgot falling space debris


I feel like you missed the biggest risk these days: failure of preflight quarantine.


One (unmanned) mission has already been accomplished without a hitch.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: