Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This has happened countless times: A very ill received proposal meets sufficient public resistance to be publicly labeled as "defeated", only to resurface in an almost identical version months/years later. It seems obvious that strong powers playing the long game are lobbying to see this passed.


This seems to have become standard operating procedure in the US, and it really kills peoples' trust of our legislative system. It's saddening to hear that the EU is not immune to it either.


The EU has been pulling this stuff for a while. Back when Ireland had a referendum whether they should ratify the Lisbon treaty the Irish voted against it. A year later they were asked to have another referendum with some concessions given by the EU.

Referendums don't really work if one side can just ask to have another one.


I would say it's standard in most western countries.


Eastern countries too, unless they're too totalitarian to hold votes.


That is probably a property of representative democracy.


It's a property of all systems. Some asshole is going to try to abuse it to enrich themselves. That's why checks on power are so important.


Just a legal version of "keep voting until we get the vote we want".

But it shouldn't be shocking that the elites get what they want. The EU was created by the elites for the benefit of the elites, not ordinary europeans.

The elites of every major region seem intent on controlling and censoring the internet ( EU, China, Russia, US, etc ). The question is towards what end? It certainly isn't for the benefit of their own people.


> The EU was created by the elites for the benefit of the elites, not ordinary europeans.

Citation needed.


I assumed it was self evident. All major organizations ( especially international organizations ) are built by the elites. Who else has the time, money, influence and knowledge to create international organizations?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_European_Union


That’s sort of a truism, then. Because obviously building a large international organization is sufficient to consider you part of the elite.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: